Pour warm apple cider into tall mug. The cider can be microwaved until heated through.
Pour in Fireball whiskey.
Add vanilla vodka.
Stir in 1 teaspoon of sugar. You can also add less if you are not into anything too sweet.
For a pretty presentation, add apple slices and anise star to mug and a cinnamon stick on rim.
Notes
PITCHER PARTY Set up a self-serve station for guests to make their own. Keep apple cider warm in a crockpot with a ladle, and set out Fireball whiskey, vanilla vodka, and other liquor options. Add mugs, shot glasses or jiggers for measuring, and plenty of garnishes like apple slices, cinnamon sticks, and star anise for that special touch.